South Africa’s Lawyer Breaks Down in Tears at ICJ Hearing!
you have the floor M Mr
President members of the Court it is a
privilege to appear again before you on
on behalf of South
Africa but it’s also tragic that we are
back here 4 months after this court
first ordered provisional measures in
this case against the state of
Israel South Africa is compelled to
appear before you with this urgent
request for provisional measures in
circumstances where the alarm sounded by
the court on 28 March
2024 that quote
all the indicators of genocidal
activities are flashing red in Gaza end
quote and in Raa in particular is
sounding louder than ever
before this is because Israel has defied
every single provisional measure
indicated by this court in its orders of
26 January and 28 March and in its
decision of 16 February February as I
stand before you today Palestinians in
Gaza are not safe they are not secure
they are still being subjected to an
ongoing and intensifying genocide at the
hands of Israel their future hangs in
the
balance Mr dupy explained in his address
the assault unfolding in Rafa the last
area in Gaza in which Palestinian life
can meaningfully be
sustained The Assault on Rafa which has
triggered this application is
inextricably linked to the ongoing
genocidal conduct being committed across
Gaza Mr
President I place before the court again
a map of
Gaza I remind the court that Gaza is
narrow strip of land of approximately
365 Square
kilm it is just 6 kilm wide the length
from top to bottom is just 44
kilm which is about the distance between
this court and skipple
airport in South African terms this is
even less than the dist distance between
Johannesburg and
Petoria Rafa lies in the south of Gaza
with an area of approximately 60 square
kilm this time last year Rafa was home
to around
275,000
Palestinians as a result of Israel’s
Onslaught and its evacuation orders
covering more than 34 of gaza’s total
territory 1.2 million additional
Palestinians fled into Rafa under order
of Israel as a place of last
Refuge now Israel has issued further
evacuation orders directing Palestinians
to leave
Rafa in just the past week 600,000
Palestinians have been forced to flee
from
Rafa but with nowhere to go there is a
total collapse of infrastructure of
Sanitation of water of food
supply in short the conditions necessary
to sustain life for the 2.3 million
Palestinians in
Gaza the picture on the screen shows
Palestinians last month starting to
return to their homes after Israel’s
withdrawal of its
occupation of K
yunice as we can all see there is
nothing
left Israel’s most recent actions in
Rafa bring its coordinated plan aimed at
the disr destruction of the essential
foundations of Palestinian life in Gaza
into horrifying Focus we are in the
final stages of that coordinated plan
where the different actions of Israel to
use Lenin’s
terminology the systematic
disintegration of the political and
social institutions and the economic
existence of national groups and the
destruction of the personal security
Liberty Health
dignity and even the lives of
Palestinians have led to the present
precipice Israel has the power over each
and every Palestinian man woman and
child in
Gaza to determine if they live or how
they
die history warns us what happens
next we cannot simply stand by waiting
for that to happen
again it is not possible to recount
every story of every Palestinian who is
suffering at the hands of Israel’s
Relentless genocidal
campaign indeed this court has held in
Bosnian
genocide
that quote it is
sufficient to examine those facts that
would illuminate the question of intent
or illustrate the claim by the applicant
of a pattern of Acts committed against
members of the group such as to lead to
an inference from such pattern of the
existence of a specific
intent end
quote in these
submissions I show that Israel’s
genocidal acts against Palestinians in
Rafa form part of a continuing
escalating pattern of conduct across
Gaza that provides persuasive and
consistent evidence of Israel’s
genocidal
conduct in light of these new facts
South Africa seeks an order from the
court the only
order that will clearly protect what is
left of Palestinian life in Gaza it
seeks an explicit order that Israel
cease its militaries military
activities not only in Rafa but
throughout
Gaza turning then to the genocidal
acts in my remaining time before you I
will highlight the following features of
the genocidal campaign by
Israel
first Israel has continued to kill
Palestinians in Gaza including women and
children at an alarming
rate second as a result of Israel’s
Onslaught Palestinians in Gaza are
facing what the under Secretary General
of the UN has described as the worst
humanitarian crisis he has seen for more
than 50
years
third Israel’s systematic targeting and
bombardment of hospitals and medical
facilities and its throttling of
humanitarian Aid has pushed gaza’s
medical system to
collapse fourth Israel’s direct
attack and Siege of gaza’s biggest
hospitals has led to the uncovering of
mass Graves evidencing Israeli massacres
of Palestinians seeking
shelter and medical
treatment
finally most recently Israel has
intensified its attacks in the north
while pressing on with its rougher
offensive leaving displaced Palestinians
nowhere safe to
go I will take these in
turn the first feature of the genocide
conduct
killing since South Africa appeared
before the court on 11 January
2024 at least
11,500 Palestinians have been directly
killed by
Israel the majority of these casualties
are women and children in an enclave
where nearly 50% of the population our
children this Onslaught has occurred
despite the binding orders issued by
this court and The Binding Security
Council
resolution on 25 March
2024 demanding an immediate ceasefire
for the month of
Ramadan in fact as UNICEF pointed out a
double digigit number of children were
killed K within hours of that
resolution two mothers and four children
are killed every
hour unra head Philip lazarini
says there are no words left that can do
any justice to the people of
Gaza the numbers of dead and injured
defy
comprehension at least 35 ,000
Palestinians killed and 79,000 injured
with 10,000 more reportedly missing or
under the
rubble up to 1.7 million
displaced most multiple
times and More than 70% of all housing
stock in Gaza and more than 80% in parts
of Northern Region damaged or
destroyed the second feature
is a humanitarian
catastrophe Israel’s coordinated plan in
Gaza has resulted in a humanitarian
crisis the crisis that this court warned
about in January
February and in
March what Palestinians in Gaza
face has been described as quote
apocalyptic levels of pain and Injustice
given that food and other vital Aid
cannot get in and people including the
chronically sick and injured cannot get
out end
quote these
apocalyptic conditions look set to
worsen with Israel’s ongoing attacks on
the North middle and South will full
with full-blown famine in the north
moving its way south and where Israel’s
blockade on food Fuel and medical
supplies
continue gaza’s children have suffered
particularly
severely more than
14,000 have been
killed thousands more have been injured
or lost family
members while an estimated 177,000
children are unaccompanied or
separated nearly all of gaza’s
children have been exposed to traumatic
experiences the consequences of which
will last lost a
lifetime make no
mistake these conditions are a direct
result of Israel’s military Onslaught on
The besieged Enclave with full knowledge
of the destructive consequences of this
humanitarian
crisis in these
circumstances in these circumstances
the thwarting of humanitarian Aid cannot
be seen as anything but the deliberate
snuffing out of Palestinian
lives starvation to the point of
famine obstructing Aid in the face of
famine and killing of at least 200 Aid
workers for the Court’s previous orders
to be effective for the provision of
humanitarian Aid
urgently and at scale Israel has to be
ordered to stop its military
offensive the third
feature of genocidal
conduct relates to the crippling of
gaza’s medical
system Israel’s offensive on Rafa has
further reduced Access to Health Care in
an already decimated Health System only
two out of 36 hospitals are located
within the
so-called humanitarian area designated
by Israel in just 6 days between 6 and
12 May met Sansan Frontier recorded that
it was forced to suspend its life
sustaining activities at Al shabura
Clinic hand over its
activities at alir
hospital and was forced to close its
activities in Rafa Indonesian field
hospital as it could not guarantee the
security and safety of patients and
staff with the ongoing
offensive The Assault on healthc care
within Rafa is the culmination of a
pattern of attacks on Healthcare
Services in Gaza through which the main
hospitals across Gaza have completely
stopped
functioning after Israel’s military
assault pardon me after Israel’s um
military
seized the Rafa and Kem Shalom Crossings
last week and prohibited the importation
of lifegiving fuel to hospitals on 13
May the European Gaza Hospital
completely ran out of fuel and
experienced a total blackout
without fuel hospitals cannot sustain
incubators respirators and life-saving
Machinery healthc care in Gaza is
crippled by shortages of food fuel
oxygen medicines and
anesthetics the obstetric and maternity
health system in Gaza is virtually
nonexistent and every functioning
medical facility is overwhelmed with
patience babies continue to die of
malnutrition and
starvation nor is there any
Escape medical evacuations are
impossible Israel has seized control of
all entry and exit points into and out
of Gaza trapping an already suffering
population and inflicting conditions of
life
calculated to bring about Palestinians
physical and biological destruction in
clear violation of Article 2 C of the
genocide
convention the fourth feature of
genocidal
conduct is the discovery of mass
graves in its targeted attack on
hospitals Israel has killed killed
hundreds of civilians including doctors
and medical staff turning centers built
for healing into Mass Graves full of the
decomposing bodies of men women and
children on 10 April a un Inspection
Team reported that KH Unice was reduced
to rubble and dirt and
rures discovered ghastly scenes of
Unearthed Mass Graves containing the
massacred bodies of the elderly women
children and men at al- Nasa
Hospital blue scrubs reportedly still
clothed the dead bodies of medical
staff many were
decapitated 300 and 24 decomposing
bodies were
discovered many stripped and
handcuffed of these only 42 were
identified another 30 bodies were
discovered in two Mass graves in alifa
hospital with only 12 bodies
identified prompting the UN Secretary
General to call for the immediate access
of independent
investigators these bodies included
women and children with many reportedly
showing signs of torture and summary
executions the recent discovery of
multiple Mass Graves Israel’s ongoing
Chokehold on information coming out of
Gaza and complete refusal to allow
independent investigators
in means that we will not know
how many Palestinians have been killed
by Israel’s military campaign for some
time if at all and only if the evidence
is not
obliterated by Israel’s ongoing military
operations in what commissioner vulka
Turk describes as the prevailing climate
of
impunity it is for this reason that
South Africa seeks an order requiring
Israel to facilitate the unimpeded
access into Gaza of fact finding
missions officials investigators and
journalists the fifth
feature of genocidal conduct relates to
Israel’s intensified attacks in the
North during the past
week while our eyes and attention were
drawn to the horrific acts unfolding in
Rafa Israeli tanks rolled again into
Northern
Gaza an area that Israel reported that
it had cleared many months ago on 11 May
Israel issued evacuation orders over 22
neighborhoods in jabalia in Northern
Gaza at least 100,000 people in the
North have been forced to flee their
devastated
homes that same day that same day of the
evacuation
orders Israel began a Relentless assault
on Northern Gaza killing Palestinian
families in their homes and children
near the Toba mosque within the jabalia
refugee
cramp journalists report that they have
no idea
about the number of people killed in
North Gaza for the past day as Medics
are unable to move due to the heavy
bombing many people are still trapped
under the rubble waiting for rescue but
no one is able to move under the Reigns
of
bombs as I stand before you Mr President
it
continues on 14 and 15 may just
yesterday
and the day before yesterday the Israeli
military issued two new sets of
evacuation orders for all or part of 19
neighborhoods in Northern
Gaza
displacing even more Palestinians in
search of
safety Mr
President these are the credible
facts Israel will no doubt
out once again deny and cast aspersions
on the information presented by South
Africa and provided by the UN and other
International actors including those
this court itself has relied
on it will do so while continuing to
systematically attack all independent
sources of information about what is
taking place in Gaza and refuse
International investigators and
journalists entry into
Gaza having denied access to Gaza and
attempted to discredit all other sources
of information Israel is then free to
portray a picture of Gaza radically at
odds with all other
accounts just yesterday the prime
minister’s
office
proclaimed that quote the humanitarian
catastrophe that has been spoken
of has not been realized nor will it end
quote a bold denial of the findings of
un experts and other independent
agencies such as the
IPC as this court pointed out the IPC is
a global Partnership of organizations
including amongst others the world food
program the food and agriculture
organization of the UN and the World
Health
Organization
ultimately Israel says only what suits
them only if and when it suits them not
withstanding the facts on the ground
that have been presented here
today despite the court providing Israel
with an
opportunity to respond to South Africa’s
current
request Israel has failed to submit a
response in conclusion Mr
President members of the
Court the risks to the people of Gaza
are
imminent irreparable and rapidly
increasing this
risk gives rise to the necessity for the
remedy that we seek in this application
a remedy that will end Israel’s
genocidal campaign against Palestinians
in Gaza all of what I have described
must
stop Israel Must Be Stopped South Africa
is before you again
today to respectfully ask the court to
invoke its powers under article 752 of
the rules of the court to order a remedy
that will stop
Israel Mr
President that concludes my submissions
on the genocidal
conduct I thank you for your patient
attention and I ask that you call Mr
Nuka toi to the podium to address the
court on genocidal intent